CiviCRM Community Forums (archive)

I have (successfully) implemented Memberships, using Webform Integration, and it's OK to create or modify (actually replace) one Membership (between one Organisation and one Member).

But some of my Members can have 2 different Membership Types (and Statuses) in the  same Organization (e.g. President and Teacher) (which Civi enables).

If I re-use my Webform to create a second Membership : it won't : actually it will replace the old one by the new one (which is safe).

I can modify my Webform to create 2 different Memberships : that works for creation ... but not for modification (or replacement) : only one is modified (the second one).

Any idea about how I should manage that ? Thanks in advance.

Hi Coleman,

Thank you for your answer
I use Webform 7.x-4.2 and Webform Integration 7.x-4.10

- creating 2 Memberships with the same Webform (with 2 Membership fields) works fine : both Memberships are created

- my problem is with modification, which does not (only one Membership is modified : the second one, as I can see)

(In fact, Contacts don't access the form themselves : as an admin, I do create the Membership(s) myself with the form ... but I don't think that this changes anything)

Hi Coleman,

Thank you for your proposal :

Create one Organisation, with 4 Membership Types (let's say A, B, C, D)

Create a Webform with :
Contact 1 = Organisation (existing Contact)
Contact 2 = Individual (existing Contact)
2 Memberships, each with :
  . Membership Type (select)
  . Membership Status (select limited to Current / Cancelled)

Now, view your Webform :
Select the Organization
Select one Individual
Select 2 memberships (e.g. A and B) with "current" status
Submit

Now, view your Webform again (for modification) :
Select same Organization and Individual
Select 2 different memberships (e.g. C and D) again with "current" status
Submit

Now, in CiviCRM, select the Individual and open his memberships : I would personally expect C and D memberships (but I get A and D)

Thank you again